13,519
edits
Talk:Main Page: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
Undefishin (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Undefishin (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (64 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
|
Welcome to the Wiki Standards! This is where discussion and documentation of the standards and guidelines for how bootleg articles should be written take place. Don't forget to include your wiki signature if you add commentary here, and have fun!
= Table of Contents =
__TOC__
= Wiki standards / Guidelines =
If an article does not meet the wiki standards, use this template to mark articles as such, named Not met:
{{Not met}}
{{Not met|Reason goes here.}}
This template serves as a marker for others to look at and rectify if needed.
== Bootleg article formatting (perpetually WIP) ==
=== Bootleg Infobox ===
Anything that is optional will be marked as such, otherwise it is mandatory. (Unless it's the archive addition date, in which case, it has not been tracked extensively, only very recently. If you can't find the exact date, ask others about it, otherwise specify "Unknown" in the archiveadd value.)
When you are copying and pasting this Infobox bootleg template, remove the comments (and the newlines after them) after you have filled the necessary parameters in.
It is advised that you do not include a newline after the Infobox bootleg template, as you will end up with an annoying bar at the top of the article.
For more information on the Bootleg infobox template, see its TemplateData.
<pre>
{{Infobox bootleg
|title =
// title (Optional. You can remove the title
|collection_name = Windows
// collection name (Optional. Use Windows, Linux, MS-DOS, the rest
|screenshot = (PUT SCREENSHOT HERE)
// desktop screenshot (
|screenshot_size = 250px
|caption = (CAPTION HERE)
// screenshot caption (Optional. Unless the screenshot is not showing the Desktop screenshot (in that case you specify this to reflect the screenshot), you shouldn't have to specify this)
|original_os = [[:Category:Bootlegs based on (OS NAME HERE)|(OS NAME HERE)]]
// original os (Use category links instead of seperate articles (
|forked_from =
// bootleg fork (Optional. Use this if the bootleg is evidently based off of another one)
|release_date = 20
// release date (The date format is: Month Day, Year. Ordinals should not be used. If you don't know the exact day/month, just put in the year and their early/mid/late part. If you don't know the release date, either look in the ISO
|creator = [[:Category:Bootlegs created by (CREATOR NAME HERE)|(CREATOR NAME HERE)]]
// bootleg creator(s) (If the bootleg creator(s)/group has made more than 2 bootlegs, make it a link to their own category, otherwise just put in their name(s)
|country =
// countr(ies) (Optional. If you know the author's country, then specify this parameter
|language =
// system language(s) (Include multiple languages if the bootleg has a different regional language, or it has software in other languages
|arch = (ARCHITECTURES HERE)
// architecture(s) (The architecture format is: x86 (16-bit), x86 (32-bit), x86 (64-bit). Only specify the necessary architectures
|othervers =
// file size(s) (The size format is: X.X Y (#.# floating number, Y size unit (In capitals)).)
|download =
// download link(s)
|archiveadd =
// archive addition date(s) (The date format is the same as the release date's format.)
|timebombdate =
// timebomb date (Use this parameter for bootlegs based on operating systems in the beta stages, which don't have their timebomb already patched out)
|livecd =
// live cd (Use this parameter for marking Live CDs)
}}
</pre>
=== The article itself ===
<pre>
'''(Bootleg name)''' (also known as (other name(s) if any) is a bootleg (describe bootleg here (e.g. (reference original_os from infobox) edition, live (ditto) CD, etc), which was created by (reference creator from infobox). It released on (reference release_date from infobox), and was added to the archive on (reference archiveadd from infobox)
The bootleg is a modified (reference original_os from infobox) ISO. (Specify any integrations the bootleg comes with. For example, the DriverPacks version, RyanVM, etc). It comes with its own boot selector (if any). (Describe the purpose of the bootleg and what is added and what is removed, in brief). It comes with its own autorun (if any), and WPI (if any
It is (unattended (and/or) preactivated). (if available:) The
(Feel free to put newlines and format neatly when necessary.)
== Changes from (reference original_os from infobox) ==
(This section, along with Software, and Notes, should be split into 3 sections.)
(In here there will be the subsections Minor changes, Changes in pre-desktop procedures, and Look and feel.
In it, you should document all the places changes were made in the respective sections, such as the text-mode and graphical setup, boot screen, OOBE (including the pre-OOBE, and the OOBE video), login graphics, themes, wallpapers, screensavers, icons, cursors, sounds, fonts, avatars, and OEM branding.
Where goes into which ones should be clear as a result of these names being chosen, and therefore this new policy being inducted.)
(If there is absolutely no software bundled, then it's optional. Most of the time, it isn't.)
(The software listing goes here. The software list needs to be sorted by software type, in their own sub-sections. Some specific software types include Customization Utilities (software made to modify the look and feel of Windows, e.g. ViStart, TrueTransparency, Vista Drive Indicator, WindowBlinds, etc), Updates (Visual C++ redistributables, .NET Framework, etc) and Screensavers. Any others can be included if necessary. This includes the WPI, which will be explained in more detail below this comment.)
(If the bootleg has a WPI, or "software packs", add a new sub-section named "Software on the CD", and put them in this section. If it's software packs, add another sub-section under "Software on the CD" named "Software Pack 1", if there is more than one, then make more than one section, and then include all the bundled software from there. It must be sorted exactly how it is shown in the WPI.)
== Notes ==
(If there is nothing to note, then it's optional.)
(The notes listing goes here. If you can find anything particularly interesting about the bootleg you are making an article on, then feel free to put it in here! The first places you should look are: Full names, organizations, computer names, workgroup names, what interesting things are in the CD root, if the CD has its own icon, anything notable about the autorun, etc.
This section is subject to the same subsection policies. The main sections are Bootleg quirks, CD contents and other info and WINNT.SIF metadata. The last section depends on what version of Windows the bootleg is based on, which will likely vary. If it is Windows Vista or later then it should be System information.)
== Gallery ==
(The gallery goes here. For themes, and other miscellanea, put them in their own sub-sections. The Bootleg Gallery section also covers this.)
To see how to properly create the gallery where all screenshots of the bootleg are, see the Bootleg Gallery section.
</pre>
=== Where to look to obtain information for... ===
==== Infobox parameters, particularly... ====
===== forked_from =====
If you've looked at a bootleg before and then check another bootleg, and if you notice any similarities between the two, then you should look for more evidence to confirm if it's forked or not. Try comparing the two ISO's together and doing some digging. Good examples of forked bootlegs are [[Android XP]] vs. [[Skype XP]], and [[Windows 7 FaceBook Edition 2012]] vs. [[Windows 7 Angry Birds Edition]].
=====
Check the ISO for the most recent file date you can find. It is highly recommended to look for any "release notes" or README's, as those can have valuable information, in some cases more so, than just the bootleg's release date. However, you should always look at the bootleg's original submission (as in looking in #bootleg-submissions for the post about it) for the release dates (and any other information). Asking others can do wonders, as well.
===== creator =====
It can be difficult to determine the original author at times, but it should be pretty easy. Looking at the bootleg's submission entry and asking others about it can be pretty beneficial too. It is highly recommended that you consider using these methods as the last line of defense, if you really can't find a necessary piece of information.
==
You can usually infer the author's country by simply just looking at the system language, but you can also attempt a background check on the author to find their country.
===== size, download =====
You can find the size by literally just looking at the ISO itself. If it's already in the collection, it's asinine - look at the size column of the pertaining ISO entry, and use that as the size. The download link is really easy to find too - you can simply just copy and paste the link from the Crusty Windows collection.
===== othervers =====
Try looking around for other versions.
===== archiveadd =====
The first places you should look are:
* [[Project:Changelog|The Wiki changelog]]
* The Wayback Machine (see [[Project:Changelog|the Wiki changelog]] for details)
* [[User:Yellows111/All Bootlegs By Filename/XP|yellows' XP bootlegs by filename]] (to get a general idea of the release date)
* Simply ask around (it's always faster to look for it yourself, but you really won't get an answer anywhere else in some cases)
; You will need to be in the Crusty Windows Discord server to access these destinations.
* [https://discord.com/channels/1070582862698520667/1070840062578794627 #collection-updates] (very useful resource, this will usually do the trick)
* [https://discord.com/channels/1070582862698520667/1109895513366593579 #bootleg-submissions] (there will be usually a comment saying "Added" or similar, from there you can infer the addition date, goes back to May 21, 2023)
* [https://discord.com/channels/1070582862698520667/1070591801272062024 #bootleg-submissions-archive] (the original bootleg-submissions channel, before it got replaced with a forum channel for easier organization, same procedure for bootleg-submissions, goes back to February 2, 2023)
===== timebombdate =====
Use the same method you use to find the build number of a beta build. If you don't know, then just look in the system files for a version number and you'll find it. Or better yet, use Winver to get the build number. Then it's just a matter of looking the build up and getting the timebomb date. BetaWiki and other such sites will usually have it.
==== Characteristics of a bootleg, particularly... ====
===== The tools used to make a bootleg =====
To confirm if a bootleg was made with nLite or not, look:
* For any <code>WINNT.SIF</code> or <code>WINNT.ORG</code> file and look for a "Generated by nLite" line at the beginning of the document, for example:
: <code>; Generated by nLite 1.3</code>
: <code>; Generated by nLite 1.4.9.1</code>
: <code>; Generated by nLite 1.4.9.3</code>
* The version number may be different - there have been cases where bootlegs were made with really old versions going back to 1.0 or even beta versions of nLite. You should include this version number in the "This ISO was made using ..." portion if possible. Ditto for all the other tools with visible version numbers.
* Any files named <code>nlite.inf</code> and all INF files for the keywords "nLite" including comments (usually at EOF) in <code>I386</code>
* The line <code>"rundll32 advpack.dll,LaunchINFSection nLite.inf,U"</code> in the file <code>cmdlines.txt</code> in the folder <code>$OEM$</code>. This will also confirm the existence of <code>nLite.inf</code> in <code>I386</code>, which is the file that holds the component tweaks done by nLite according to the user.
To confirm if a bootleg was made with Windows Unattended CD Creator or not, look in:
* A file named <code>settings.txt</code> in the CD root, and if it contains a comment with the keywords "Windows Unattended CD Creator" as the first line of the file.
* A file named <code>RunOnceEx.js</code> or the entry <code>wucdcreator="wscript.exe %systemroot%\RunOnceEx.js"</code> or similar in <code>WINNT.SIF</code>. This is the most used feature of Windows Unattended CD Creator, its software post-installer.
To confirm if a bootleg was made with VistaPE or not, look in:
* A file named <code>VISTAPE.CD</code> in the CD root
To confirm if a bootleg uses any boot selectors or not, look in:
* The bootleg's bootloader code itself, obviously
* Any folders named "EZBOOT" or "CDBOOT" with any files with a EZB extension (''EasyBoot'', most common), "AIRBOOT" (''Aero Studio'', also common) "BCDW" (''Bootable CD Wizard'', mostly used in Russian bootlegs), or "BOOT\cdshell.ini" (''CDShell'', uncommon) in the CD root
To confirm the program used to make a bootleg's autorun:
* Look for any files pertaining to the autorun maker itself, such as:
: A file named "AUTORUN.CDD". Any "Docs" / "dat0X/ap0X.dat" entries, in an "AutoPlay" folder. (''AutoPlay Media Studio'', most common)
: A file named "SETUP.INI" with any mentions of "Авторан для Windows", or sections "Default" and any "Item" entries (''Advanced CD Launcher'' by Boa Software, mostly seen in Russian bootlegs)
: A file named "AUTORUN.ARU" (''Longtion Autorun Pro/Enterprise/II'', usually seen in Vietnamese bootlegs)
: A file named "AUTORUN.APM" (''AutoPlay Menu Builder'')
: A file named "AUTORUN.EXE" which is packed with ASPack, the Visual Basic 6 runtimes and OCX files in the root, along with any "Data" folders with files with "pic" and "esr" extensions (''Power AutoPlay Menu Creator'')
* ''For autoruns made with StartCD:'' Click the program's icon at the top left of the program window, or right click the program in the tasklist, and click "About"
* Check the file's version information
* Search for strings in the binary itself. It may lead you to extra clues such as version information which you may not be obvious otherwise
* You may use any binary checking tool, such as Detect It Easy, to help you
To confirm the program used to modify the bootleg's ISO / what software was used to make the ISO:
* If you use the program PowerISO, open the ISO image you desire, go to Tools > View / Edit sector data..., then view the LBAs 16-18. There you will find:
: CDImage (a sign that the ISO was created manually)
: Markers for e.g. UltraISO, Nero, etc.
===== The methods used to integrate various objects in a bootleg =====
To confirm if a program was integrated via an nLite addon:
* Your first stop is the <code>SYSOC.INF</code> file in the I386 folder. Look for an nLite entry, and check both directions of the entry for any entries pertaining to certain INF files. Some examples:
: Most software programs. Usually repacked by ricktendo64 and others
: DirectX, Microsoft .NET Framework, any other updates
: "WGAV", "WGAN", "Microsoft Update Engine", "XP SP3 Update Pack", "OUE/OGA". Addons usually by xable
: Any entries starting with "RVM". This is a reference to "RyanVM", a person well-known for making nLite addons and update packs
: Any entries starting with "Z-". This is a reference to "Zab". Mostly seen in Russian bootlegs
* Second is to look for the nLite session files (usually in the root of the CD or hidden somewhere) and scroll to the very end, it may reveal filenames which may be important to identifying and cataloguing them.
To confirm if a program was integrated via the setup hotfix feature:
* Usually, they will be in the SVCPACK folder, but be sure to check <code>SVCPACK.INF</code>. It may be especially important if it's in a different folder (CatalogSubDir entry), the specific order of installing programs (SetupHotfixesToRun section), product catalogs (ProductCatalogsToInstall section) etc.
== Bootleg Gallery ==
To create a gallery in the Source Editor, just expand the Advanced section and click the Gallery button next to the "Insert" label, and fill everything out. The procedures to do this are covered below.
For Visual Editor users, click the Insert dropdown, then expand it by clicking More, then click Gallery.
All screenshots '''must''' be captured in PNG format. Screenshots should be taken in a VM screen (doesn't matter how you get a VM running) and if the screenshot is taken from a hypervisor, be cropped to just the VM screen (for obvious reasons).
You can use the hypervisor's screenshot function if it has it, and any hypervisor that is applicable for testing the bootleg. Although you ''can'' just use the Install Any OS VMs (or soon, Crusttest, which is nearly done, but not yet ready for public release. It will come in handy for later, but for now it is not applicable) using a virtual machine is highly recommended, as you don't have to deal with distractions and disruptions from any potential troublemakers that can arise in using a public environment, and you get a higher quality picture as there isn't any JPEG compression from the server.
=== Labeling your screenshots and formatting it in its own gallery ===
As for labeling your screenshots, and good places to look for capturing, this is how to label your screenshots:
Example:
<code>XP Magart Redivo 2010 DJ KHALED theme.png</code>
<code>Vista X360 Ganja Edition Desktop.png</code>
And as for places to look, here are a few good places to look:
You must order the screenshots in the gallery in the way that the portions down below are ordered. You can only take one of each screenshot, and if there are multiple sections of one portion, it doesn't exclude it from capture. The Desktop, Start Menu, and Demo portions must always be included, even if it's unchanged from stock. Do not attempt to alter or change anything in the bootleg, and try to keep everything as is in its default configuration. An exception to this is if the resolution is raised to 1024x768.
Try to maintain a consistent resolution of 1024x768 across all screenshots, if possible. The reasoning behind that specific resolution is because it is a good balance of size and content. (That being, it's not too big or small, and just about everything else will properly fit in that resolution without any cramming).
; Pre-boot selector / Boot selector (''if it exists'')
; Text-mode setup (usually the only changes here are string changes, that is better suited for the 'Changes' section and not worth screenshotting)
; Graphical setup (most of the changes here are a lot more visual)
; Boot screen
; Pre-OOBE (
; OOBE video (
; OOBE (''if it exists, some bootlegs omit this'')
; Login screen
; Pre-desktop (''anything that is set to run on startup, such as a WPI, post-install script, or other such. this section directly succeeds the login portion'')
; Empty desktop (''if anything else is shown when you first arrive to the desktop, such as a WPI screen, a popup (like a welcome center or other such), a system shutdown prompt, etc, then that makes it a Desktop on First Boot portion, otherwise it's just a Desktop portion'')
; Start menu (''the start menu of the default theme'')
: Don't forget to specify the default theme's name when you're captioning the Start Menu image. You can find it by simply opening the Display Properties applet and reading off of the default theme in the theme dropdown field.
; Demo (''a Demo portion involves showcasing various system and user information dialogs, where there will usually be changes. the list of the programs involved will be included in its own listing'')
: If you're doing the Demo portion, and the programs are too big even after resizing them, take separate screenshots of them. If you're on Windows Vista and later, use the AeroShot(CRE) utility instead.
: System Properties (''usually there will be OEM branding'')
: Support Information (''if it exists, then include it'')
: Run dialog (''if it's changed'')
: About Windows (''usually there will be changed branding'')
; Autorun (''if the bootleg has its own one'')
: Autorun splash, and post-exit screens (''if any'')
; WPI (''if the bootleg has one'')
: The WPI installation dialog
; A picture of an Explorer window of the CD root or the C drive (''if it has a custom folder background'')
This is the minimum baseline for taking screenshots. You can take screenshots of
Remember, screenshotting portions count towards the Changes section, and '''must always be included'''. That being said, if there is a pre-OOBE screenshot, it counts as a "New pre-OOBE graphics" change. If there's a Setup screenshot, it's "New setup graphics".
=== Structure of a themes gallery ===
What is also important to capture are the themes of a bootleg, as there are many bootlegs with many themes (and we do mean many, there are [[Windows 7 Infinium Edition|known bootlegs]] with more than 100 themes), so this is how to deal with it:
You must take a screenshot of the theme by applying the theme in the theme selector
As for labeling it, you do it like this: <code>(
As for captioning it in the gallery, you do it like this: <code>"(Theme name)" theme</code>. You can also append the internal theme name if the theme selector's name doesn't accurately represent what it is, but it takes more time to caption in bulk. Example: <code>"(Theme name)" theme ("(Internal theme name)" theme)</code>.
If the theme has any other names, you title it like this: <code>"(Theme name)" theme ("(Theme name 1)" theme, "(Theme name 2)" theme)</code>.
It is generally recommended to leave everything in its default configuration, and not change anything when you're capturing bootleg screenshots.
= Wiki standards discussion =
== Linux articles ==
Do we really count [[Linux]] as bootlegs? its crusty, sure but bootleg? that's debatable [[User:Yellows111|yellows111]] ([[User talk:Yellows111|talk]]) 12:55, 4 January 2023 (UTC)
: Counter-point: [[Windows 12 Lite]] exists, so i'm not sure what to say about this topic. Huh. [[User:Yellows111|yellows111]] ([[User talk:Yellows111|talk]]) 16:03, 4 January 2023 (UTC)
== Screenshot Criteria Discussion ==
=== Version 1 ===
* If stock assets are used, do not bother capturing, if filler is needed, then this clause can be changed to "use the template image of File:X_Y_(Stock)"
* <s>A gallery must not use the same image as the infobox's screenshot parameter</s> No longer affected with recent changes.
* Never use the same image twice (EXCEPT the infobox image). Doing such will break galleries. Nobody wants that.
* by [[User:Yellows111|yellows111]] ([[User talk:Yellows111|talk]]) 13:31, 1 February 2023 (UTC)
== Template Standards ==
* If you use an image for the love of all crust in the sky PLEASE make your file references have a empty link parameter. (<nowiki>[[File:whatever.png|link=]]</nowiki>)
* Not doing the above makes the template image able to be clicked on and thus previewed by MediaViewer. This makes for a bad user experience where the first image can be a random icon.
[[User:Yellows111|yellows111]] ([[User talk:Yellows111|talk]]) 13:38, 1 February 2023 (UTC)
=== Program screenshots ===
Screenshot examples:
<gallery>
</gallery>
On Windows, you can also hold ALT + Print Screen to capture the window. I don't know when this was added but I know it works on XP, 7, and 10. [[User:Dartz|Dartz]] ([[User talk:Dartz|talk]]) 20:46, 7 February 2023 (UTC)
As for the Alt + PrtScr feature, the best way to use this feature is to take advantage of the shared clipboard feature found in the guest additions of hypervisors such as VirtualBox, VMware, etc. First, you enable the Shared Clipboard feature itself, then you configure it to be able to copy from Guest to Host. (or Bidirectional, either one). Then, you paste the clipboard's contents into an image viewer/editor (such as IrfanView, which I use) and save it there. As for labelling the screenshot, again, see "Labeling your screenshots and formatting it in its own gallery". --[[User:Undefishin|Undefishin]] ([[User talk:Undefishin|talk]]) 11:57, 9 December 2023 (UTC)
== How to deal with multiple bootlegs with the same name ==
If you are trying to write an article on a bootleg and a bootleg with the same name (but not same author) as the one you are trying to review exists, you have to move the original page and rename it accordingly, preferrably by appending the author's name in paranthesis at the end of the article name, and then you can make
=== Alternatively, how to deal with multiple ''versions'' of bootlegs ===
--[[User:Undefishin|Undefishin]] ([[User talk:Undefishin|talk]]) 09:00, 23 March 2023 (UTC)
== How categories should be ordered ==
--[[User:Undefishin|Undefishin]] ([[User talk:Undefishin|talk]]) 07:44, 7 May 2023 (UTC)
== Attribution Policy ==
We, (Crusty Windows) have had multiple issues related to attribution for the documentation we provide, which makes the Wiki Staff disappointed, as there could be helpful people that could be referred here which may have some undocumented material that we didn't even know we were looking for.
Thoughts? [[User:Yellows111|yellows111]] ([[User talk:Yellows111|talk]]) 15:48, 16 May 2024 (UTC)
| |||